Fics like They're Alive?

When investigating a series of violent murders in a small town, JJ and Reid have the misfortune to stumble upon the Winchester brothers.

You may also like

1. The Unquiet Soul by I_Am_A_Silver_Lining (Supernatural (TV 2005))
2. Unnatural by DontTalkToMeAboutLife (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
3. (NOW ILLUSTRATED!!) counting or not counting destiel (Supernatural (TV 2005), My Chemical Romance (Band))
4. Investigating the Winchesters by Dark_Nymphs_translates (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
5. No Road Back by Dapi12692 (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural (TV 2005))
6. buried deep, these memories by forgetmesunflower (Batman - All Media Types, Criminal Minds (US TV), more)
7. Missing Piece by stridermagic (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Criminal Minds (US TV))
8. Postcards from Hell by volchitsa70 (Batman - All Media Types, Criminal Minds (US TV))
9. Fortunate son by onlyonestraightcouple (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural (TV 2005))
10. The Bunker by LightAndHeat (Criminal Minds (US TV), Criminal Minds: Evolution (TV))
11. Of Bats, Birds, and BAU Agents by Asocial_Lobster (Criminal Minds (US TV), Batman - All Media Types)
12. you're never gonna be like anyone and that's okay by whateverislovely (Criminal Minds (US TV))
13. A Safe Place by serpent_selective (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
14. The Fourth Horseman by NinjaPandaScholar (Supernatural (TV 2005), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
15. Little Lost Things by Ravens_Game (Supernatural (TV 2005))
16. Lone Survivor by audioaujom (9-1-1 (TV), Criminal Minds (US TV))
17. Single Malt, Double Life by mind_of_emmette (NCIS (TV 2003), Criminal Minds (US TV))
18. Hail Mary, Mother of Grace by EchoOfWrens (Project Hail Mary (2026), Project Hail Mary - Andy Weir, more)
19. The Difference Between Villain and Criminal by PiedPiperWrites (Criminal Minds (US TV), Batman - All Media Types)
20. Strange But True by NothingEitherGoodOrBad (Criminal Minds (US TV))