Fics like Stalking the Horse Girl

Eli is a loser with a crush on the most popular girl in school. He’s so infatuated in fact, he can’t help but follow her home and see something he didn’t expect in the slightest.

You may also like

1. The Barn Bet by OculusTales (Original Work)
2. Spreading Seeds by OliphantBreedlove (Original Work)
3. The Fugitive and the Well-Hung Equine: A Montana Love Story by DKing1311 (Original Work, No Fandom)
4. pls help by orphan_account (Original Work)
5. A Call To Breed by TheGoblinWitch (Original Work, Monster Girls | Monster Boys)
6. Cyclic (Original Work)
7. Deep Dive by pinkriffic (Original Work)
8. One horny fucking horse by orphan_account (Original Work)
9. Mans Best Friend by orphan_account (Original Work, No Fandom)
10. alone together forever by agentofaquarius (Original Work)
11. The Girl Who Dreamed by clairelutra, volpish (Original Work)
12. From Thief to Vixen by Shirokuro_Jesus (Original Work)
13. Isobel Koen and Achilleus the Great Dane (Original Work)
14. Overflowing joy by fluffnsmut (Original Work)
15. Choose Your Smut: Liviand by ChooseYourSmut (Original Work)
16. Alien Abduction by orphan_account (Original Work)
17. Nighttime Swim by orphan_account (Original Work)
18. Get Into the Robot by FennyWrites (Original Work)
19. The Ways In Which A Queen Gets Her Revenge by BiscuitDragonWithAStick (Original Work)
20. The Misadventures of Nix by orphan_account (Dungeons & Dragons (Roleplaying Game), World of Warcraft, more)