Fics like Stay with me?

As his eyes fell upon your slouched figure on the red bench, rolling your eyes in boredom at whatever your friend was prattling on about, Art realised he had either made a grave mistake or stumbled upon something incredibly right.

You may also like

  1. The Horror of HEADCANNONS (Film) by MurkyMoth (Friday the 13th Series (Movies), Malignant (2021), more)
  2. Tidings of Comfort and Joy. by The_Leftovers (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  3. Good and Evil: The Gates of Hell (Part 1 of 3) by MysterioMan007 (Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), The Omen (Movies), more)
  4. Morbid Ecstasy [Art the Clown x Reader] by Doves%20In%20A%20Pot (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  5. Varying Degrees of Violence. by orphan_account (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  6. Little Slasher Sister (Child Reader x Slashers) by CrazyClownAuthor (A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
  7. You'll Ache To Know My Name by shamevillain (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  8. An intervention for Art the Clown by Aragorn_II_Elessar (A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
  9. To be loved by death (Art the clown/reader) by Octernity (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  10. O Come, All Ye Frightful by shamevillain (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  11. blood & glitter by doublydeviousdoublydamned (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  12. Unholy Pursuit by orphan_account (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))
  13. Horror Movie Headcanons by macabrebatz (House of Wax (2005), Hellraiser (Movies 1987-2018), more)
  14. Lethal Devotion by AnimeKidKT (Psycho (Movies 1960-1990), Friday the 13th Series (Movies), more)
  15. ♡︎Mummy Dearest ♡︎ by heathive (Black Christmas (1974), The Boy (Movies - Bell), more)
  16. Revival: Explorations of the Psyche in Media (Original Work, Knight Rider (1982), more)
  17. Red Skies' Devil May Cry by Jiren_Kirishima1, TheGrimoiresVoice (Devil May Cry (Gameverse), Devil May Cry (Cartoon 2025), more)
  18. Beyond the Grave {Slashers X reader} by maddie_the_MnM_lover (Halloween (Movies - Zombie), Child's Play | Chucky (Movies 1988-2017), more)
  19. Horror Movies Headcanons II by macabrebatz (IT (Movies - Muschietti), Terrifier (Movies - Leone), more)
  20. Cemetery Girl by WitchyB00 (Terrifier (Movies - Leone))