Fics like Caught and Kept

“I’m not a prize for your sick game,” he rasped, and Superman chuckled. “Oh but you are,” he said, tracing the outline of the bat on Bruce’s chest now, “I’ve caught you, and now I get to have you.”

You may also like

1. The Interview by Icannotthinkofapenname (DCU (Comics), Batman - All Media Types, more)
2. Under Twin Moons by cavesongs (DCU, Batman - All Media Types, more)
3. take what you want, i'll give it all to you by nepobebe (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types)
4. arancello by ceann_cinnidh (The Batman (Movie 2022), Batman - All Media Types, more)
5. Together We'll Build a Garden by TiniestGoblin (Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, Justice League (2017), more)
6. One Small Step for (Super)man by frozenpotions (DCU (Comics), Superman - All Media Types, more)
7. Padam Padam by frozenpotions (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types, more)
8. there ain't no star that shines by amosanguis (Batman - All Media Types, DC Extended Universe, more)
9. so willing by TheResurrectionist (Batman - All Media Types)
10. welcome-ish by mikaminato (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types, more)
11. Satisfaction Brought It Back by SpiritsFlame, slippin_into_darkness (DCU (Comics))
12. undercover by mikaminato (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types, more)
13. Banana Muffin by Mawiiish (Superman - All Media Types, Batman - All Media Types)
14. rainy days by mikaminato (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types, more)
15. The New Son of Krypton by Sally_Boomer (Batman - All Media Types, Superman - All Media Types)
16. Man of Steel, Man of Heart by capsicleonyourleft (DCU (Comics), DCU)
17. #Superbat by lostinreeverie (DCU (Comics), Superman - All Media Types, more)
18. isostatic by mediant (Superman - All Media Types, Batman - All Media Types)
19. You Can Leave Your Hat On by TheResurrectionist (Batman - All Media Types)
20. Use Your Words by Mawiiish (Superman - All Media Types, Batman - All Media Types)