Fics like Surprise!

Sam goes swimming at the beach near his new house and accidentally walks right into a tentacle monster's grasp.

You may also like

1. An Honorary Degree in Cryptozoology by BiscuitDragonWithAStick (Original Work)
2. Too Late by thedeadestofdoves (Original Work)
3. The Fic With Eggs And Gay People, Part 2 by defnotthatguy (Original Work)
4. The Deep Gods by RedSnowWhite (Original Work)
5. Dorian and the Nymphs by ofsecretsandshame (Original Work)
6. Mother Of The Moth by orphan_account (Original Work)
7. Limited Edition by orphan_account (Original Work)
8. A new set of armour by Btsese (Original Work)
9. The Fic With Eggs And Gay People by defnotthatguy (Original Work)
10. The Beast by I_Read_Super_Fucked_Up_Shit (Original Work)
11. Squishy Situation by CheezyDC (Original Work, No Fandom, more)
12. A-peel-ing Nightmare by DLManoir (Original Work)
13. Morning by the Beach (part 3) by DLManoir (Original Work)
14. Continuing Education Credits in Cryptozoology by cfeo2_ad (Original Work, Fanfiction of Original Work - Fandom)
15. Aiding in Repopulation (Original Work)
16. Sy Rho's Intergalactic Guide to Tentacled Beings by JB_Lark (Original Work)
17. Forest Hole Debauchery by bonerfics (Original Work)
18. but without the sun, I'm only shadows in a dress by fabulous_but_evil (Original Work)
19. Toy to you by NonAnon3rd (Original Work)
20. tangle me up in your vines (take my spirit, take my mind) by auraofcorruption (Original Work)