Fics like For the First Time Twice

An encounter with an enchanted puzzle box locks up most of Charles’ memories and leaves him thinking he and Edwin are in love. With a recipe from Tragic Mick for a potion to counteract the spell and strict instructions to go along with Charles' delusions, all Edwin has to do is keep up the ruse for three days. He can make it three days. Right?

You may also like

  1. Of a youth who loves me by Aliquis (Dead Boy Detectives (TV), The Dead Boy Detectives (DC Comics))
  2. And possibly I like the thrill (of under me you quite so new) by Leandra (Dead Boy Detectives (TV), The Sandman (TV 2022))
  3. I Turned Back One Last Time (just to prove you were there) by isnt_that_wizard (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  4. touch my tears with your lips (touch my world with your fingertips) by ObsessedWithFandom (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  5. after the insects have laid their claim by lolotr (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  6. Imagine Being Loved by Me by IntoTheUnknown (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  7. if i could reach the stars (i’d give them all to you) by ObsessedWithFandom (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  8. Partridge in a Pear Tree by Vamillepudding (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  9. Tonight's the Night You Fight Your Best Mate's Dad by Opossum_Subatomic (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  10. Lovely Poison by tragedy_machine (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  11. i'll tell them put me back in it by intrajanelle (Dead Boy Detectives (TV), The Dead Boy Detectives (DC Comics))
  12. You'll Love Me At Once (the way you did once upon a dream) by grayskiesandstars (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  13. Hold This by RoseGanymede95 (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  14. what some circumstance stole by Chrome (The Sandman (TV 2022), Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  15. When We Walk Together We Tend To Walk Alone by UneducatedAuthor (Dead Boy Detectives (TV), The Sandman (TV 2022))
  16. The Case of The... by sophisticatedyet (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  17. my healing needed more than time by babyseraphim (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  18. Closed Telemark by RoseGanymede95 (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  19. bring your chains and fall into my arms by Cesare (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))
  20. Mine, Says the Cat by merle_p (Dead Boy Detectives (TV))