Fics like first time for everything

you and james have quite the eventful night while he’s babysitting you...

You may also like

1. Sketchbook by orphan_account (Metallica, Megadeth)
2. A Little Offbeat by astrella_noctis (Rammstein, Music RPF, more)
3. The Results of Yesterday by TheFirstKilljoy (Bandom, My Chemical Romance)
4. back in the cage by jehoney (Danger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys - My Chemical Romance (Album), The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys: California (Comics), more)
5. Filthy Lucre. by risky_business (Panic! at the Disco, Fall Out Boy, more)
6. A Little Infamy by ladyfoxxx (Bandom, Fall Out Boy)
7. Beatles NSFW alphabet by iheartjohnlennon (The Beatles (Band), Rock Music RPF)
8. Heartbreaker by whiplasher (Metallica, Megadeth)
9. Eden Burns by coricomile (Bandom, Fall Out Boy)
10. (Not Your) Pretty Woman by JulianJoyStark (Metallica, Megadeth)
11. Love, Hate, Love by Addicted2u (Alice in Chains, Pearl Jam, more)
12. A Modern History of Witchcraft in New Jersey by lllookalive (My Chemical Romance, Cobra Starship, more)
13. Play the Game (Take the Band Real Far) by peachgal743 (My Chemical Romance, Bandom)
14. Loverman by JulianJoyStark (Metallica, Megadeth)
15. Burning Star by orphan_account (My Chemical Romance, Danger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys (Album), more)
16. Patrick Stump/Reader One Shots by Impala_Boys (Fall Out Boy, Bandom)
17. I’d swallow poison if it tasted like you by suizzide (Metallica, Megadeth)
18. Anything Goes by scaryhours (Guns N' Roses, Rock Music RPF)
19. Mutt In Training by puptorox (My Chemical Romance, Bandom)
20. The Amateur Film Crew In Apartment Six by breakorburywearasjewelry (My Chemical Romance (Band), Bandom, more)