Fics like The Way We Began

Arthur Morgan thought nothing of it when he lassoed the O'Driscoll boy off his horse in the middle of the snowy mountains, returning him to the gang as their prisoner. But as it turns out, their latest captive has a secret, which, once uncovered, changes Arthur's worldview, forcing him to re-evaluate his perspective on the work they do, and his future within the gang.

You may also like

  1. Every Breath You Take by Nigaki (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  2. Soldier, Poet, King by nerdytf84fan (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  3. C'mon fellers, I'm just a kid! by Brysh (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  4. Turn Back The Clock by glorifiedturkey (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  5. Kinktober 2025 (video game men x reader) ୨ৎ by sinonimgirl (Biohazard | Resident Evil (Gameverse), The Last of Us (Video Games), more)
  6. Mercy a Thing For Gentler Climes by TheWaffleBat (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  7. i'd tell them put me back in it by scrolling_upp (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games), Red Dead Redemption 2)
  8. And In The Morning I Loved You Too by pipdepop (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  9. Daddy's Gun by felmonk (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  10. American Apple Pie by ApplePieSupreme (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  11. The Matthews Family by deal_at_the_crossroads (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  12. Are You Arthur Morgan? by knivesintheirfeet (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  13. Tell A Story That Is Only Mine by pipdepop (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  14. Valuables by surveycorpsjean (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  15. The Silence of the Dead by Supdudes95 (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  16. Samaritan by fallen_arazil (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  17. One Last Time by whyyouacknsocraycray (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  18. Blessed Are the Hearts that Bend (They Shall Not Be Broken) by Disishistory (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  19. A soul full of kindling, a light in the dark (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))
  20. Sunrise by pipdepop (Red Dead Redemption (Video Games))