Fics like The New Teacher

A new substitute teacher arrives at Abbott Elementary to teach second grade. From the start, teaching here is hard. The admin sucks, the school is old, and you are constantly distracted by an italian-sicilian red head. However, what starts as dislike is leading into an obsession... Edit: I stopped writing this fanfic, so the ending is a bit abrupt.

You may also like

1. what's a loss of blood when you win a bit of dirt? by the_frankenman_writes (Abbott Elementary (TV))
2. Sweet Cheeks - Melissa Schemmenti x OC (wlw) by gay4women00 (Abbott Elementary (TV), Melissa Schemmenti - Fandom, more)
3. Forever Is The Sweetest Con by callmeyours (Abbott Elementary (TV))
4. Sorry, Hon. by earpivore (Abbott Elementary (TV))
5. what’s heaven to a woman’s love anyway? by beanierose (Abbott Elementary (TV))
6. You Learn To Lick It Off Knives by bonesofsapphire (Abbott Elementary (TV))
7. Fictional Milf Oneshots by lyssiesroses (Multi-Fandom, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
8. Out. by literary_lesbian (Abbott Elementary (TV))
9. Little Pitchers by dionaeamuscipula (Abbott Elementary (TV))
10. stop the world i wanna get off with you by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
11. Ladies of the Evening by dionaeamuscipula (Abbott Elementary (TV))
12. Homegrown Tomatoes by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))
13. gladly break my heart for you by charlottepriestly (Abbott Elementary (TV))
14. Fritole by thesexfiles (Abbott Elementary (TV))
15. Sec On The Beach by gaynahmontana (Abbott Elementary (TV))
16. The Fish Lady by Leontopodiumnivale (Abbott Elementary (TV))
17. I Choose You Every Day by Scarlet_Widow_3000 (Abbott Elementary (TV))
18. Somebody's Son by callmeyours (Abbott Elementary (TV))
19. I was meant to love you by BadBatch (Abbott Elementary (TV))
20. Slow Dancing in the Dark by milfandhoney (Abbott Elementary (TV))