Fics like For a few dollars more

The freshly assembled Phantom Thieves discover a potential adversary in the transfer student Ren Amamiya. Skillfully, they manage to persuade him to refrain from interference, though Ann is not prepared to let him escape unscathed. Aka, AU where Ren "learned" from his mistake.

You may also like

Stygian Ringlet by CubanCracker62 (Persona 5, Persona 3)
From delinquent to criminal by gingerprick (Persona 5)
Courage, Set Us Free by InfinityBlaze (Persona 5, Persona Series, more)
Multiversal Support Chat Group by Hypn0s (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), Overwatch (Video Game), more)
Souls And Healing by Rough_TimeST0RIES (僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga), Undertale (Video Game), more)
The Age of a New Trickster by SuperShiro (Metaphor: ReFantazio (Video Game), Persona Series, more)
A Tale of Two Tricksters by Zoe2k8 (Persona 5, Persona Series)
A Self Fulfilling Prophecy by Danidoesathing (Persona 5, Persona 5 Royal, more)
With the Stars and Memories by CmGunner13, Gederas, Starlit_Sheen (Persona Series, Persona 5, more)
Persona: The Phantom Masquerade. by Phantom_Voyage (Persona 5, Persona Series)
A Multiverse Full of Problems and Potential by Phoenix_Champion (Cassette Beasts (Video Game), Dispatch (Video Game), more)
The Royal Strikers by CloudStrife07, TheNewWorldFool (Persona 5, Persona Series, more)
Throw Away Your Mask by MollyPollyKinz (Persona Series, Persona 5, more)
Phantom Dumbasses by Cipherian (Persona 5, Persona Series, more)
The World Is Ours by AristoMuse (Persona 5, Persona Series)
Do you remember who we used to be? by Infinite_Hope (Persona Series, Persona 5, more)
Oh Alice, There's no Reflection in the Looking Glass. by intothefrisson (Persona 5)
Every Ordeal Needs a Trickster by nageaT (Persona Series, Persona 5, more)
Your Desires Hold Me Like A Prison by stoorworm (Persona 5)
To Reclaim What Was Stolen From a Thief by BeeRye (Persona 5, Persona 4, more)