Fics like Bad Step-dad

Joe marries the readers mother, but he takes more of a liking to you than your mother...

You may also like

  1. Fun Times With the Hawl by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  2. Here and Ever, Hear Forever by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band))
  3. So They Circle & Fly (TalliedHallway’s Version) by TalliedHallway (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  4. where my heart resides by agnosthesia (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  5. ion wanna jump through yo hoops no mo 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 (a mildly satire fanfic) by ToLiveAndLoveAndDie (Weezer (Band), Zootopia (Disney Movies), more)
  6. Creature Hall (REWRITE) by LaplacesLawyer (Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  7. Labyrinth by mumutits_thesour (Hawaii: Part II - ミラクルミュージカル | Miracle Musical (Album), Tally Hall (Band), more)
  8. 'Apologizing.' by Lollisweet20 (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  9. Hardware Store by applefulharvest (Pressure (Roblox), Spooky's Jump Scare Mansion, more)
  10. Cicada days (TALLY HALL GOES TO FLORIDA...BUT SOMETHING GOES WRONG!) by ToLiveAndLoveAndDie (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series), more)
  11. if it's them and you and me by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  12. Ross's Secret by PerhapsTheTallyisBalling (Tally Hall (Band))
  13. 我々は天国から出発 by Plasticineporters (Tally Hall (Band))
  14. joe kills bora and goes to burn down a pride parade while breaking zubin's hand to protect andrew. and then rejects him. by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  15. ‘Cause I’m a slut for you, slut for you! by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  16. Bangbros Title Here by Aint_Nothing_Wrong_With_That (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  17. bomb rush blush by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band))
  18. Mini Piano - Andrew Horowitz Oneshots (AGE REGRESSING/LITTLE SPACE) by orphan_account (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  19. Does Anybody Else See the Ghosts Standing at My Door? by PerhapsTheTallyisBalling (Tally Hall (Band), Tally Hall's Internet Show (Web Series))
  20. Inside the Mind of Simon by thearch3rofdreams (Hawaii Pt II - Fandom, Hawaii: Part II - ミラクルミュージカル | Miracle Musical (Album), more)