Fics like Pistanthrophobia - (n.) the fear of trusting people due to past experiences

After an Anon Ask on Tumblr: While John and Amanda travel to Mexico, Reader and Mark are being left behind and forced to confront their conflicted feelings for each other.

You may also like

1. Fictober Days 1-31 by Intimacyequalsdeath (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), slasher - Fandom, more)
2. A Death Blow is a Life Blow To Some by devovitsuasartes (Saw (Movies), Insidious (Movies))
3. John's Jigsquad by Hollywood_Tower_Hotel (Saw (Movies))
4. Just a man (Just a little boy) by Syntheticpalindromes (Saw (Movies))
5. Slasher Headcanons by littleoddwriter (The Collector Series (Movies), Laid to Rest (2009), more)
6. The jigsquad by orphan_account (Saw (Movies), Spiral: From the Book of Saw (Movie))
7. Little Slasher Sister (Child Reader x Slashers) by CrazyClownAuthor (A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
8. 5 Times Mark Hoffman Was Jealous + 1 Time He Wasn't by orphan_account (Saw (Movies))
9. Kinktober 2023 by sp3xtkr (Saw (Movies), Hannibal (TV), more)
10. Cause and Effect to React and Explode by lemon_teacake (Saw (Movies))
11. Physical by smallestobject (Saw (Movies))
12. know it’s for the better by orphan_account (Saw (Movies), Spiral: From the Book of Saw (Movie))
13. lay down in my favourite place by RattyCatty (Saw (Movies))
14. Kinktober by orphan_account (Insidious (Movies), Saw (Movies))
15. your best kept secret and your biggest mistake by shirelings (Saw (Movies))
16. Year of the Pig by fiddlestick (Saw (Movies), House of Leaves - Mark Z. Danielewski)
17. I Love You, Do You Love Me? Lets Set Our House On Fire by angel_trap (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween Movies - All Media Types, more)
18. love me cruel by orphan_account (Saw (Movies))
19. Slasher Simp Bible Study by lyrical_opiate (The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Movies), Terrifier (Movies - Leone), more)
20. Before the Fog by Jack_White (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Saw (Movies), more)