Fics like Maybe More Than I Should

Eddie caught sight of the man leaning against the side of his desk and immediately wanted to retreat to the relative safety of the hallway, back in time when he lived happily not knowing that Mr. Buckley was apparently some kind of male model masquerading as a third-grade teacher. “Uh. Hi,” was all he managed, as his brain desperately tried to reconcile this person—this very tall, very broad, very hot person, Jesus fucking Christ—with the Mr. Buckley that Chris rambled about constantly, the one who loved Lord of the Rings and was an endless repository of fun animal facts. (Did you know a group of owls was called a parliament? Eddie didn't, not until last week.)

You may also like

  1. We are all born mad (some remain so)... by ReallySmartLadyMarieCurie (9-1-1 (TV))
  2. made your mark on me (a golden tattoo) by thatbuddie (9-1-1 (TV))
  3. my heart's a secret (tell me you'll keep it) by sibylsleaves (9-1-1 (TV))
  4. Untitled by MykkiTno (9-1-1 (TV))
  5. and longer by far by farfromthstars (9-1-1 (TV))
  6. a study in ripples by hobbitprincess (9-1-1 (TV))
  7. can you open up the door? by fruitsdoesnotknow (9-1-1 (TV))
  8. The sound of your voice by StarlingBite (9-1-1 (TV))
  9. for the first time, I didn’t feel alone by youdrewstarsaroundmyscars118 (9-1-1 (TV))
  10. nobody has to know by coupe_de_foudre (9-1-1 (TV))
  11. A Series of Sleepless Nights and Unfortunate Events. by StarlingBite (9-1-1 (TV))
  12. one look, dark room by markofalover (9-1-1 (TV))
  13. if i could say what i want to say by rizcriz (9-1-1 (TV))
  14. It's Not a Love Song by elless (9-1-1 (TV))
  15. Accidental Sugar Baby by Sonayesul (9-1-1 (TV))
  16. a picture of what life could be by farfromthstars (9-1-1 (TV))
  17. I'll Take Care of You by scarmaddiewrites (9-1-1 (TV))
  18. Reunited by abow123456 (9-1-1 (TV))
  19. Don't Push Me So Far Away I Can't Reach You by giselleslash (9-1-1 (TV))
  20. Eddie, My Love by amorcanis (9-1-1 (TV))