Fics like the underwear is not a joke

It’s not something that takes a long time for Sam to discover – in fact, it happens the first time they have sex.

You may also like

1. Weight of Love by Noname109 (Supernatural)
2. Be Careful What You Think Of by thirtyspells (Supernatural)
3. Grace You With My Presence by Rhiannimated (Supernatural)
4. Bind Me With Silks Invisible by jessebee (Supernatural)
5. Answering Prayers by wrenseroticlibrary_archivist (Supernatural)
6. Claimed by vlbuehle (Supernatural)
7. Gabriel’s (Literal) Gay Awakening by chelecheese (Supernatural)
8. Show and Tell by twinpaws (Supernatural)
9. Wish Upon a Christmas Star by CrowNoYami (Supernatural)
10. Eat Me E. L. James! by LadyDrace (Supernatural)
11. Mine for everyone to see by Silvaxus (Supernatural)
12. Pretty Sweet by vanishingact (Supernatural)
13. Mating Season by Miya_Morana (Supernatural)
14. Your Wings Are Showing by fanfic814 (Supernatural)
15. Angelic Behavior isn't so Angelic by IceFemme (Supernatural)
16. Cat Got Your Tongue? by Enmuse (Supernatural)
17. Gabriel Does Cancun Right (Then Does It Wrong by Falling In Love) by Aria_Lerendeair (Supernatural)
18. Work For It by LadyDrace (Supernatural)
19. What do you want, Gabriel? by orphan_account (Supernatural)
20. 178 Rejections Later by StarlightDragon (Supernatural)