Fics like offering

While going home from the Martins' house, a group of cultists stop John in the middle of the road. Their leader takes a dark interest in the priest. [Or after the ending "The Offering" in Chapter 1, Gary takes John back with him to Garyland and has his way with him.]

You may also like

1. Can We Get Some Amens In The Chat? by Lunammoon (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
2. Forty Legions by chalicechipper (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
3. We never knew what it meant to be whole and free by Amputator (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
4. too much poison, come undone by Amputator (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
5. Violent Ends, Violent Delights by thebleedingeffect (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
6. On the First Day, God Said: by silverspoongoon (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
7. Random fanart i made by MoonTheCartoondemon (Homestuck, The Amazing Digital Circus (Web Series), more)
8. god is on the radio. by Amputator (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
9. How it feels to rest (on your patient lips) by aquamarena (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games), FAITH The Unholy Trinity - Fandom)
10. Danganronpa 5000: Unfortunate Circumstances by brammster (Dangan Ronpa Series, Five Nights at Freddy's, more)
11. so don't get big ideas by neverwon (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
12. Exaltatus (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
13. endure the smoke by trains_arent_real (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
14. Sympathy For The Duke by just_existing_I_think (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
15. everytime i see you falling, i get down on my knees and pray. by Amputator (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
16. Agadez by baphomimi (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
17. ETHAN WINTERS KISSES HORROR GAME PROTAGONISTS. (Biohazard | Resident Evil (Gameverse), Silent Hill (Video Game Series), more)
18. The Vow of Chastity by silverspoongoon (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))
19. springtrap? more like exorcisedtrap! by elritch_ermine (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games), Five Nights at Freddy's)
20. Father Ward, Curse His Soul by RanbowKng (FAITH (Airdorf Video Games))