Fics like It All Started with a Milkshake

Billy is 18-year-old fat loser. While he is interested in girls, they have very little interest on him and closest he gets to a pussy, is watching porn. One day it all changes: he sees his 12-year-old sister naked in the shower. While Billy knows it is wrong, he is soon sniffing her used panties while masturbating dreaming of her pussy. When his sister finds out the secret ingredient Billy has been putting into her and her hot friends’ milkshakes, the girls decide to take revenge on Billy. But the young girls cannot control themselves as their raging hormones take their revenge much further than they initially planned.

You may also like

1. The game by orphan_account (Original Work)
2. Fucked Through Her Cervix by risque (Original Work)
3. Another Blackmail Scenario by TheManInMayonnaise (Original Work)
4. Deep Tissue Massage by Hopeful_Ink_Hoof (Original Work)
5. Safe After by this_guy20 (Original Work, ASSTReloaded)
6. Abducted! by orphan_account (Original Work)
7. A very lucky little bro by kingbigshot (Original Work)
8. Andrew's Story by this_guy20 (Original Work, ASSTReloaded)
9. Sibling bonding in the backseat during a long car ride by ZoeyBrooks (Original Work)
10. Girl Scout Ends Up Selling Her Cookie (IronShortie #8) by MrIronStorm (No Fandom, Original Work)
11. Sex Is For Little Girls Too! by toke_n_stroke (Original Work)
12. Little Sister Offers Helping Hand by YoungFoxHunter (Original Work)
13. Summer Heat (Original Work)
14. First Time by SoleraInu (Original Work)
15. Daphne & Dylan by shipcestuous (Original Work)
16. Trying to Breed My Little Sister by this_guy20 (Original Work, ASSTReloaded)
17. Kinesthetic by allyoops (Original Work)
18. It’s just a doll ~ a siblings tale by MissWritten (No Fandom, Original Work)
19. Brother Knows Best (Original Work)
20. The first time is the best time... by Luke_Harrison453 (Original Work)