Fics like Not My First

The Pend Pals finally see where Eli is from. But why is Atlas so serious about this weekend going the way his brother wants it to?

You may also like

1. soft hearts, electric souls by xylarias (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
2. echoing down by badassbutterfly1987 (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
3. the sunshine of life by homeformyheart_jen (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), Choices: The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
4. Supposed To Be by whatisreggieshortfor (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
5. Secret Studies by Elemental_air (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), Choices: The Elementalists)
6. The Elementalist Book 3 by perfectlysunny, whatisreggieshortfor (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
7. School Girl Studies by orphan_account (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
8. And So On by eliharrington (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
9. Graduation by LugianBeforeSwine (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), PlayChoices)
10. The First Solstice by SCGdoeswhat (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), PlayChoices, more)
11. Friday Nights Readings (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
12. Composure by CallMeDizzy (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
13. Feelings Are Better Expressed At Night by orcsmoocher (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
14. for you, anything by badassbutterfly1987 (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
15. Yoga & Pancakes by AlexHunt (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), Choices - Fandom, more)
16. Two sides of him (and I love both) by AestheticTanuki (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
17. Clean Break by eliharrington (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
18. Four Times Eli Hugs Atlas and One Time She Doesn't by Blackrising (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))
19. if you want to touch the sky, better learn how to kneel (The Elementalists (Visual Novel), Ancient Greek Religion & Lore)
20. The Perfect Ring by QueenPlatypus (The Elementalists (Visual Novel))