Fics like Love Tokens

Jensen is a serial killer that cuts out his victims’ heart to give to his crush, his neighbor Jared. Jared doesn't quite know what to do about the boxes of human hearts showing up on his doorstep.

You may also like

1. The Capering Damned by embersdevine (Supernatural RPF)
2. I'm Not Leaving You by morganaDW (Supernatural RPF)
3. Three Long Mountains and a Wood by Phoenix1966 (Supernatural RPF)
4. Underneath It All by ashtraythief (Supernatural RPF, CW Network RPF)
5. Over the Wall by cherie_morte (Supernatural RPF)
6. Plastic Blue Spoon by compo67 (Supernatural RPF)
7. It's Not That Big by orphan_account (Supernatural RPF)
8. (just remember till you're home again) you belong to me by itsnotsammy (Supernatural RPF)
9. Heathens by gothpandaotaku (Supernatural RPF)
10. The Sea Will Rise by Exaggerated_Specificity (Supernatural RPF)
11. Fair Winds and Following Seas by riyku (Supernatural RPF)
12. Who Watches Over Me? by nyxocity (Supernatural RPF)
13. Two Worlds Collide by Jld71, cyncitymojo (Supernatural RPF)
14. The Future is Here by waywardelle (Supernatural RPF)
15. Tennessee Honey by cherie_morte (Supernatural RPF)
16. Drifting Through Doorways by Rainywriter (Supernatural RPF)
17. Misha's Not in Vancouver Anymore by Elizabeth1985 (Supernatural, Supernatural RPF)
18. pastime by hellhoundsprey (Supernatural RPF)
19. Brand New Start by gestaltrose (Supernatural RPF)
20. My Sweet Omega by kinksock22 (Supernatural RPF)