Fics like Let Me Pretend You're Mine

After Jacks returns injured to the Hollow, Evangeline tends to his wounds which promptly turns into bed-sharing and tentative heart-to-hearts. Evangeline tells Jacks she's his (for the night, only), but that is not the way it comes out. And not, it turns out, the end of it. Or: a full, smuttier version of the night Jacks and Evangeline mutually decide to sleep together in the Hollow.

You may also like

1. Happily Ever After by bellafeir (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
2. The Tangled Foxtail by FinallyTimeless (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
3. A Heartbeat Later by dawnsnail (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
4. A Safe Place by taupe66 (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
5. New begingings by Moobell55 (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber, Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber)
6. A Promise of Everlasting Love by Leetah_Leetah (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber, Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber)
7. The Ballad of Broken Memories by ArchiveOsprey (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber, Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber)
8. tangled in love, stuck by you by didntknow (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
9. Keep Burning Me by theshymoon (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
10. It's Only a Game by AllyGreenbriar (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber, Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber)
11. Whispers in the Garden by faithdc15 (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
12. The Winner Takes It All by Halfblood_Heroine (Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber, Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
13. Everything deep loves the costume by bridgetfest (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
14. help me hold on to you by aphrodite_loves (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
15. Pluck by wispy_warlock (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
16. Cottage Longing by LxnarmxxN (Caraval Series - Stephanie Garber, Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
17. the pages we forget by lokislittleangel (The Folk of the Air - Holly Black, The Naturals - Jennifer Lynn Barnes, more)
18. sunlit mornings and strawberry hugs by underratedum (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
19. the kitchen by wispy_warlock (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)
20. dream of me by xogray (Once Upon a Broken Heart Series - Stephanie Garber)