Fics like I Couldn't Stop It

Sue is Austin's girlfriend that Emily is supposed to be meeting at a party her brother is hosting. And they do meet. Up close and....personal. Or Emily and Sue have a one night stand that leads to things getting very messy.

You may also like

1. just between us, did the love affair maim you too? by themountainsweclimb (Dickinson (TV))
2. Better than any poem by NerdySoldier (Dickinson (TV))
3. there is an indentation in the shape of you by MountainThyme (Dickinson (TV))
4. Falling in the Cape by smuttysapphic (Dickinson (TV), Emisue - Fandom, more)
5. Surreal, but nice. by afoolwhodreams (Dickinson (TV))
6. My House of Stone, Your Ivy Grows and Now I’m Covered by ljbishop (Dickinson (TV))
7. Emily Goes to School by idk_books (Dickinson (TV))
8. What's Left of our Serotonin by thenighttrain (Dickinson (TV))
9. you are here, and so am i (maybe millions of people go by) by everdeen (Dickinson (TV))
10. but i didn't do it right, can i try again? by everdeen (Dickinson (TV))
11. right where you left me by molecularblonde (Dickinson (TV))
12. if we loved again, i swear i'd love you right by for_evermores (Dickinson (TV))
13. She Once Was (a true love of mine) by MountainThyme (Dickinson (TV))
14. You Don't Love Him by smuttysapphic (Dickinson (TV), Emisue - Fandom, more)
15. this, and my heart beside by glutamate (Dickinson (TV))
16. Redemption by inkedghost (Dickinson (TV))
17. October by GlassTable (Dickinson (TV))
18. (there's a mile) between my heart and my head by everdeen (Dickinson (TV))
19. did the twin flame bruise paint you blue? by themountainsweclimb (Dickinson (TV))
20. Litmus by GlassTable (Dickinson (TV))