Fics like I Never Thought You'd Happen to Me

The day Lucy, Phoebe, and Julien notice they could possibly have feelings for each other. Not in the original way, where they thought they were all platonic soulmates, but maybe they're soulmates in other ways as well.

You may also like

1. it feels good to be known so well by orphan_account (boygenius (Band))
2. the best love song you've ever heard by gingersnap25 (boygenius (Band))
3. Secret Lust by righteousauthoritie (boygenius (Band))
4. We’d Never Go Out of Style by iheartJB (boygenius (Band))
5. heart to heart to heart (boygenius (Band))
6. i’ll just stay down by dogwithabird (boygenius (Band))
7. Black Hole by ibuprofenfan (boygenius (Band))
8. Cause im not crying wolf by sugarinthetank (boygenius (Band))
9. Gnashing my Teeth by Louloubelle21 (boygenius (Band))
10. So when it comes, my time to lose you, I'll have made the most of it by violetsfordespair (boygenius (Band))
11. Dirty Work by dogfangs (boygenius (Band))
12. full moon | phoebe bridgers x reader by revltion0 (Phoebe Bridgers - Fandom, boygenius (Band), more)
13. Good News (The Ya-Ya song) by BoyBlaspheme (boygenius (Band), Lucy Dacus - Fandom, more)
14. foot on the dash (impaled on the pass) by dogwithabird (boygenius (Band))
15. She Picks A Direction by Louloubelle21 (boygenius (Band), Phoebe Bridgers - Fandom)
16. Lean on me by ibuprofenfan (boygenius (Band))
17. Stripped Down to Our Skin by likeseriouslyellie (boygenius (Band))
18. I could never define all that you are to me by violetsfordespair (boygenius (Band))
19. i wish i wrote it, but i didn’t by dogwithabird (boygenius (Band))
20. i’m in the backseat (of my body) by dogwithabird (boygenius (Band))