Fics like Surprise.

How do you react when a sweet little girl asks you to be her little sisters god parents.

You may also like

1. Angel's Light by SavageThor (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Charmed (TV 1998), more)
2. The Serial Killing Life by Foloxcer (of the Devil (Visual Novel), Hannibal (TV), more)
3. there's a storm ahead by no_nutcracker (Charmed (TV 1998))
4. Wished Away Series by CSmalley (Danny Phantom, Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, more)
5. From Eden by Tori_cat13 (Charmed (TV 1998), The Walking Dead (TV))
6. Multitudes by gleefulmusings (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
7. Darkness Falls by Howlingwolf27 (9-1-1 (TV), Charmed (TV 1998))
8. Charmed By You by Fays_Lit (Charmed (TV 1998))
9. Champions & Wars by Aragorn_II_Elessar, Brainstorm_Sorcerer, Gussygus28, HRwriter897 (TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms, The Lord of the Rings - All Media Types, more)
10. Just Call My Name, I'm Yours To Tame by WriterMobster (Charmed (TV 1998))
11. First Born by Rangus4279 (Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), Charmed (TV 1998))
12. LIVING IN THE RED. by CaseyDixon1 (Scream (Movies), Criminal Minds (US TV), more)
13. be careful what you wish for because you might get your way by victoriousscarf (Charmed (TV 1998))
14. the human heart that shatters over and over (but still lives) by BeautifulHalfBlood (Charmed (TV 1998))
15. Kinktober 2024 by stridermagic (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Batman (Comics), more)
16. KINKTOBER '25 by SpookyBeanWrites (The Boy (2016), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
17. The Mission of Harley Stackhouse by buffy0201 (True Blood (TV), Charmed (TV 1998), more)
18. I Must Confess: I’m In Love (With My Own Sins) by Donkie (Scream (Movies))
19. Champions of universes by Bl4ckHunter (Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
20. the victim | billy loomis x reader x stu macher by eulogysingr (Scream (Movies))