Fics like Like We're Made Of Starlight

As the oldest in a large family, and her father serving overseas, Santana Lopez leaves the city to tend bar in a tiny Fire Island town. Almost immediately, the female captain of a fishing boat catches her eye and calls into question everything she knows about right and wrong, and everything she knows about herself.

You may also like

1. Don't You Dare Look Back, Just Keep Your Eyes On Me by LeighKelly (Glee)
2. they took the midnight train (goin’ anywhere) by that_one_urchin (Legacies (TV 2018), Glee)
3. If My Heart Was A Compass by santana-lopez (Glee)
4. Two Ghosts by WheresMyNaya (Glee)
5. Curious Minds by Peter_Pandemonium (Glee)
6. Loving You Is Easy by MrsCriss2012 (Glee)
7. Lopez's 8 by WheresMyNaya (Glee)
8. Lost in the Lights by WheresMyNaya (Glee)
9. Cherished Affliction by CherishMimi (Glee)
10. Finding the Way Back by LeighKelly (Glee)
11. you and her loathing this cruel world by thememoriesfire (Glee)
12. Leo and Aquarius by sarcasticscully (Glee, Brittana - Fandom)
13. For You I'd Burn the Length and Breadth of Sky by yumi_michiyo (Glee)
14. A Pretty Good Bad Idea by tsleaze (Glee)
15. Coffee Breaks by WheresMyNaya (Glee)
16. They Say Bad Things Happen For A Reason by lynnearlington (Glee)
17. Sing to me Instead by heartsmadeofbooks (Glee)
18. Rough Beginnings by tothevision (Glee, Faberry - Fandom)
19. White Shadows by goodafternoon (Glee)
20. miles away, all your time is heaven sent by therestisconfetti (Glee)