Fics like To My Surprise...

Nick and Gatsby have become very close with one another and the tensions are high. Nick finds himself alone with Gatsby in the study, romance, wine, and music is all it takes to win over Nick's dear heart.

You may also like

  1. A New Road by sewer_seance (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  2. Saving Grace by sea_level (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  3. Can't Buy Me Love by flibbertygigget (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  4. The Consequence of What You and I Have by Miscellaneous_mess (The Great Gatsby (2013), The Great Gatsby (1974), more)
  5. The Golden 20's by Clxarke (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  6. Nick's No Consolation Prize by lithicsgirl (The Great Gatsby (2013))
  7. Make it count, Meet me at the clock by thevictorianghost (Titanic (1997), The Great Gatsby (2013), more)
  8. Something Akin to Falling in Love by williamastankova (The Great Gatsby (2013))
  9. tell me nothing lasts (like i don't know) by mouwwie (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013))
  10. life is a highway (i wanna ride it) by 1oo (Spider-Man - All Media Types, Cars (Pixar Movies), more)
  11. tender curiosity by PaintedVanilla (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013))
  12. What is this feeling (so sudden and new?) by k4ffeinated (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  13. Colds and Confessions by ProjectFiction (The Great Gatsby (2013))
  14. Across the Lifetimes by inmyownreality (Julius Caesar - Shakespeare, Les Misérables - All Media Types, more)
  15. And They Were Roommates by sewer_seance (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013), more)
  16. back against the wall, tripping when you're gone by brightbluerose (The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013))
  17. The Sights and Sounds of the Roaring 20s by feathershollyandgolly (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald)
  18. Into The Past by feelingtwofootsmall (Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (2013))
  19. You are my favorite 'what if', you are my best 'I'll never know'. by frooley (The Great Gatsby (2013), Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald, more)
  20. Anything for you by clokkerfoot (The Great Gatsby (2013))