Fics like You Can't Steal What Is Willingly Given.

You have potential and you are wasting it on an idiot like Chris Hooker but they are going to show you that you can have a lot more fun with them than you ever could with him.

You may also like

1. Die for me, Living Dead Girl by AmnesiaMilk (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
2. Slasherbastard Matchups by slasherbastard (House of Wax (2005), House of 1000 Corpses (Movies), more)
3. The Serpent Crown by MidNightWarrior (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
4. someone to hear your prayers by eicilux (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
5. Five times by Darlingsnow0 (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
6. Four Corners by meowgnus_c (Cinderella Boy - Punko (Webcomic), The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
7. Nine Career Paths for Witches by LeBibish (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
8. The Mission to Silas by GOTFa2 (D.E.B.S. (2004), Ginger Snaps (Movies), more)
9. In Between by minkyumami (House M.D., The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
10. Welcomed. by BornToBeBeheaded (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
11. A Chaos in the Making by burningmytears (Red White & Royal Blue - Casey McQuiston, Red White & Royal Blue (2023), more)
12. Dont glance at me, glare. by AmnesiaMilk (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
13. Still Here Breathing by GOTFa2 (Jennifer's Body (2009), Ginger Snaps (Movies), more)
14. Crimson Touch by mosscoveredfae (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020), The Craft: Legacy (2020))
15. The Infectious High School AU by DeadBeyond (Homestuck, Doctor Who & Related Fandoms, more)
16. Snow for Love by dwinchestersgirl88 (9-1-1 (TV), The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
17. I Forgive it All as it Comes Back to Me by eviegreyog4 (Twin Peaks (TV 1990), Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), more)
18. might start cutting 'em short by beerdrinkingapp (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))
19. Are you in a Cult? by Moon_Dust2108 (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020), 僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia (Anime & Manga))
20. say the word by jigsawbarbie (The Craft (Movies 1996 2020))