Fics like Lemme Make It Up to You

Pizzahead turns up at Peppino's one day with a freshly made pizza and a proposition that sounds too good to be true.

You may also like

1. Pizza Pizza by saccharinemachine (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
2. Did Someone Ordered a Pasta Stuffed Pizza? (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
3. Rap Battle Ideas S30 by TheGametimer (Epic Rap Battles of History (Web Series), Multi-Fandom, more)
4. Mozzarella Maze by Maraienna (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
5. Real and Fake by meatcircus (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
6. Pizza Dinner (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
7. SMG4's New Super Duper Plus Ultra Gameshow by NootNoot64 (SMG4 (Web Series), Grim Adventures of Billy & Mandy, more)
8. peppino, gustavo, peppino by synths (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
9. Take a Breather by BigPinkStrawberry (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
10. Pizzahead's Toy by Squishybellies (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
11. Liquor License by men4ce_red (Pizza Tower (Video Game), ANTONBLAST (Video Game))
12. Perfect by SoudaPoppin (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
13. sweet nothings by carbonsoup06 (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
14. Danganronpa 256: Despair Overflow (old and dead and lifeless) by fellow_existor256 (Wii Sports (Video Game), Among Us (Video Game), more)
15. Gattino Bagnato by BoobleDoodle (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
16. Unholy Matrimony in the making by Craftycats115 (ANTONBLAST (Video Game), Pizza Tower (Video Game))
17. Just One More by JustALilLoser (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
18. Coffee and Conversation by coolfire333 (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
19. Stuffed Crust by Squishybellies (Pizza Tower (Video Game))
20. Rap Battle Ideas S32 (Video Game Rap Battle edition) by TheGametimer (Epic Rap Battles of History (Web Series), Multi-Fandom, more)