Fics like When The Pretty Lie

Elliot's sister Alice beings home her new boyfriend and he finds himself falling in love with him.

You may also like

1. Dog-Girl Academy: Otherwise Known As Bitches Galore! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
2. Nova Needs a Wife! by Wantaro (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
3. All Fun and Games by DragonRose35 (Furry (Fandom), Original Work)
4. Busty Bullies! Revenge-Sex Against the Bully Trio! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
5. Over Seas, Cover Blown by ThakurCat (Original Work)
6. Fox Mothers Prefer Human Lovers by 3AMSeedDemon (Original Work)
7. Clara and Artemis: Futa and Male Make For Lucky Lovers! by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
8. A Summer's Secret Passion by Mr_MINUS32 (Original Work)
9. Dogsitting by DragonRose35 (Furry (Fandom), Original Work)
10. A Lesson in Pleasure by DragonRose35 (Furry (Fandom), Original Work)
11. The Spoiled Prince by DragonRose35 (Furry (Fandom), Original Work)
12. A Completely Normal Journey Through Kanto by DSWriting (Pocket Monsters | Pokemon - All Media Types, Pocket Monsters SPECIAL | Pokemon Adventures, more)
13. Naughty Knotty Hellhound Pup-Making! by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
14. The Tales of Prince Anonymous by TheHonorableAjax (Furry (Fandom), Original Work)
15. QUICKIE: The Horny Logic of the Fox-MILF RPG! by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))
16. There's No Way I Got Assigned To My Older Sister?! The Story Of How The Anthrostate Gave Me An Unthinkable Marriage by marumarun (Furry (Fandom), adhg - Fandom, more)
17. THE DOLLHOUSE by Underage_Productions (Original Work, Lolita - Fandom)
18. Shark-Girl Streamer Has an Insatiable Fetish for Human Cock! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work)
19. Transported To Another World Now I Must Rebuild My Harem by Amoren (Furry (Fandom))
20. Make the Thieving Wolf-Girl your Wife! (x Male Reader) by BigBustyBnuuy (Original Work, Furry (Fandom))