Fics like The Spare

What if the fire never happened? Ciel Phantomhive is a sickly boy who lives with his parents and his twin brother. As the earl's second son, Ciel will not be inheriting anything from his father, not his title nor his wealth. He is just a spare, living under his brother's shadow. One day, when he's sixteen, Ciel comes across a demon and they make a deal that would change their lives forever.

You may also like

Those Gentle Slopes that Lead to Hell by Severus_divides_into_H (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
The Formula of the Fall by Filotes_0 (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
The Demon's Mate by BadBadz (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Inextricable by Mishka_kitty (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Revelations by haldolhs (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Devilish Impulses by KittyGetsLoose (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
i thought that you were so beautiful (it was love, i guess) by ghostlypink (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
An Earl and His Demon Butler by BadBadz (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Crossroad Blues by Darlingvioletta (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Coattails by The_Pied_Avocet (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
La Petite Mort by bun_o_ween (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
The Butler, His Possession by The%20Eternal%20Scribe (Harry Potter - Fandom, Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
A Slow and Steady Seduction by AnimeCujo (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
If I cross the line by Literal_Satan (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Watching their Anime | Season 1 by STARS_OFTHENIGHT (呪術廻戦 | Jujutsu Kaisen (Anime), 文豪ストレイドッグス | Bungou Stray Dogs, more)
Ciel Phantomhive, Sebastian’s Mate by Mermaid886 (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler, Kuroshitsuji, more)
Dancing in the Dark by AngelPinkFall101 (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
A Phantomhive in Night Raven College or A Butler, in Twisted Wonderland, or One Hell of a Twisted Tale by Darkspellmaster (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler, Twisted-Wonderland (Video Game))
One Hell of a Nanny by HeinousWriter (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)
Fever by soulless_lover (Kuroshitsuji | Black Butler)