Fics like My Sister?

Nick doesn’t realize that you, his sister, are dating Chessy. Apparently everyone else knows.

You may also like

1. THE DEVIL INCARNATE by sad_sadist (Multi-Fandom, Stranger Things (TV 2016), more)
2. Tangled Together by GhostWritingNightmares (The Parent Trap (1998))
3. Music Of Her Heart by Morgana_Larkin (The Parent Trap (1998))
4. shut up and deal by fayevalent1ne (The Parent Trap (1998))
5. Operation Chunky Man by sweetreverie (The Parent Trap (1998))
6. The Parent Trap (If It Occurred on Middle Earth) by felepa_findora (TOLKIEN J. R. R. - Works & Related Fandoms, The Hobbit - All Media Types, more)
7. The Parent Trap by randomshygirl (WandaVision (TV), The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
8. The Sister Trap by Dolphelecat (The Parent Trap (1998))
9. Parent Trap by Irish80sgirl (Suits (US TV 2011), The Parent Trap (1998))
10. Snooker by Minne_My (Matilda (1996), The Parent Trap (1998))
11. You Might Be Sleeping by milfandhoney (The Parent Trap (1998))
12. All Some Children Do Is Work. by Lanna%20Michaels (The Parent Trap (1961), The Parent Trap (1998))
13. (it's been so long, but if you ever think you got it wrong) i'm right where you left me by MellarkandArt (Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies), Iron Man (Movies), more)
14. cosmic by janewestin (The Devil Wears Prada (2006), Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, more)
15. let’s stay together (or not) by sora_grey (The Parent Trap (1998), The Parent Trap (1961))
16. more than just a game for two by onekisstotakewithme (The Parent Trap (1998))
17. Parent Trapped by foreverAvJ (Stranger Things (TV 2016), The Parent Trap (1998))
18. Second Time's the Charm by malsseong (The Parent Trap (1998))
19. The Parent Trap (Loustat AU) by murfsrambles (Interview with the Vampire (TV 2022), The Parent Trap (1998))
20. Parent Trap by LilacChocolate (SEVENTEEN (Band), The Parent Trap (1998))