Fics like To Believe In The Stars

Castiel is the only unmated beta in his herd. With his fertile time running out, he has accepted that he will always be alone. All of this changes when a pack of hunters, broken up by a bad storm, seek shelter with his herd.

You may also like

1. Of Sweet Things by orphan_account (Supernatural)
2. Honeydew by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
3. Failed Movie Night by orphan_account (Supernatural)
4. Uninvited But Deeply Craved by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
5. Only kisses by Nachsie (Supernatural)
6. Assorted Tumblr Ficlets [Supernatural] by xylodemon (Supernatural)
7. Heat and Happiness by RedheadedSuperhero (Supernatural)
8. Our Dads Play Matchmaker by DaydreamSea (Supernatural)
9. You're The Good Thing by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
10. This Could Be the End of Everything (or the start of something new) by dreamedofwings (Supernatural)
11. Getting Messy by Valinde (Supernatural)
12. A More Fruitful Bond by orphan_account (Supernatural)
13. The Shattered One by MissAnnThropic (Supernatural)
14. The Tenderness of Blood-stained Hands by SillyBlue (Supernatural)
15. Knot Supposed to Happen by magicalmuser (Supernatural)
16. Tradition Can Go Screw Itself by HigherMagic (Supernatural)
17. Satin and Lace by fanfic814 (Supernatural)
18. Sincerely Yours by heyacas (Supernatural)
19. Fighters by elizaye (Supernatural)
20. Marked by GoldenGooseFreckles (Supernatural)