Fics like An Unexpected Turn of Events

What happens when Derek realizes that contrary to his belief, there were guys who found his keener step-sister attractive?

You may also like

1. There! Right There! by Loverlylo (Life with Derek)
2. Stranger Than Fiction by NeoVenus22 (Life with Derek)
3. All I Ever Wanted by SpikedCoffee by SleepyVulpini (Life with Derek)
4. break the silence by illicitaffair (Life with Derek)
5. Love Given Unsought by ConcordiaChaos (Life with Derek)
6. A Lesser Known B-Side by kithmet (Life with Derek)
7. Flip Reverse by unoriginal_liz (Life with Derek)
8. she is the sunlight by StarlightReverie (Life with Derek)
9. this is the room one afternoon (I knew I could love you) by PinkGerberaDaisies (Life with Derek)
10. ground rules by segs (Life with Derek)
11. 'cause you’re the one that sparked this by irish_urn (Life with Derek)
12. forget it by Thetwelfthletter (Life with Derek)
13. even if it's a lie by anniebibananie (Life with Derek)
14. Rush by Thetwelfthletter (Life with Derek)
15. In Truth (and Otherwise) by kithmet (Life with Derek)
16. College Casey and Derek by Sfndhi (Life with Derek)
17. ∞ by RollyPratt (Life with Derek)
18. Playin' Back in Stereo by Rahmi (Life with Derek, Drake & Josh)
19. Surprisingly Good by adamisalive (Life with Derek)
20. Different for Girls by unoriginal_liz (Life with Derek)