Fics like Sleepy Hollow

Beware the quiet ones.

You may also like

1. always keep my heart safe by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
2. The Hunt by onsunnyside (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
3. Kinktober 2023 by myfictionaldreams (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
4. trucker king by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
5. THE PRINCESS' SEVEN MERCENARIES | CEVANS!VARIOUS X READER by kquil (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), The Gray Man (2022), more)
6. sweet as honeycrisp by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
7. The Lie by misshoneybee (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
8. overexposed by illiterate (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), more)
9. En Voyage by onsunnyside (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
10. Kinktober 2021 | Humiliation & Being Shared w/Andy Barber x F!Reader x Ari Levinson by butimaficwriter (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), Defending Jacob (TV 2020))
11. Little Fears by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
12. a fruitful afternoon in the strawberry field by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
13. that secret place in the garden by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
14. The First Date by paperweight91 (Knives Out (Movies), The Gray Man (2022), more)
15. Melting by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
16. E-Vite 4/20 by BoxofBones (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))
17. Fraternal Instincts by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
18. the murder at evergreen university by thyme_in_a_bubble (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
19. Break Up With Your Boyfriend by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), Snowpiercer (2013))
20. Flamingo King by onsunnyside (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019))