Fics like I Think I Lost My Halo

Tyler is a gay Christian questioning his faith and becoming increasingly uncomfortable with being stuck in his last semester at a Catholic boy's boarding school. Josh is a devout Christian suffering increasing guilt at his attraction to men. When the boys end up lab partners at the start of last semester, Tyler finds a new good little Christian boy to lead astray, and Josh finds new reasons to feel guilty. But if it's so wrong, then how can being with Tyler feel so right?

You may also like

1. Buy Handmade by jjtaylor (My Chemical Romance)
2. The Majesty of Choice by Helena_Hathaway (My Chemical Romance, Panic! at the Disco, more)
3. Gerard Way's Kink Service by LiberXI (My Chemical Romance)
4. 500 Baskets by emeraldcitydowntowngirl (Bandom, Twenty One Pilots, more)
5. i'm never what i like by skellybonesremain (Twenty One Pilots)
6. Hunter Green by insusurro (My Chemical Romance)
7. Skin of the Canvas by sinsense (My Chemical Romance, Bandom)
8. Heaven Help Us by Bexless (My Chemical Romance)
9. Through the Trees by modern_dion (Bandom, My Chemical Romance, more)
10. In Repair by autoschediastic (My Chemical Romance, Bandom)
11. Dreamers at Best by flightlessnerds (Twenty One Pilots)
12. Lessons in Teaching by starrswillfade (Twenty One Pilots)
13. sing it for the n00bs by jedusaur (Danger Days: The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys (Album), Bandom, more)
14. Fuck and Run by 1_800_FRERARD (My Chemical Romance)
15. We Could Fly Far Away by Pinkstationfrerard (Twenty One Pilots, Bandom)
16. hit-and-run from the third base line by dogproblems (Twenty One Pilots)
17. she (within the measure of a day) by vesna (My Chemical Romance)
18. The Anatomy of a Fall by novembersmith (Bandom, My Chemical Romance)
19. In Darkness, You'll Be My Rock by orphan_account (Twenty One Pilots, Bandom)
20. A Natural Reaction to Rough-housing by Bexless (My Chemical Romance)