Fics like Cookies and Matches

“Why aren’t you opening your eyes?” “Natsu, if something ridiculous is in front of my face, I’m going to roundhouse kick you out of my apartment.” “Just open your eyes!” - Natsu can't figure out what to get Lucy for her birthday, and in the process of asking around, the guild realizes that Lucy hasn't been able to celebrate a single birthday while in the Fairy Tail Guild. - AKA: Everyone Loves Lucy, but Natsu loves her the most

You may also like

1. The Key(s) to Victory by riddlethis (Fairy Tail)
2. Occupational Hazards by star_on_a_staff (Fairy Tail)
3. Become the Light of Heaven by Bekbek (Fairy Tail)
4. Headspace by Amajjzy (Fairy Tail)
5. Devour the Light Of Heaven by Bekbek (Fairy Tail)
6. Dragon Season by CelestialPrincess_03 (Fairy Tail)
7. your heart, my heart by aitnes (Fairy Tail)
8. Assembly Required by indraaas (Fairy Tail)
9. i’ll make you a promise (watch you dance with your keys) by tetsuryu (Fairy Tail)
10. Nalu - A twist in time by Amara22 (Fairy Tail)
11. the (-3) year quest by orphan_account (Fairy Tail)
12. Dreams of Dragons by therealnarnia (Fairy Tail)
13. Turning Tide by lilacSkye (Fairy Tail)
14. Borrowed Power, Endless Love by Raspberry_Lemonade (Fairy Tail)
15. Disoriented by Amajjzy (Fairy Tail)
16. Scars by Amajjzy (Fairy Tail)
17. everyone loves lucy by Toasted_Waffles (Fairy Tail)
18. Here by Nickedimus (Fairy Tail)
19. Hide and Seek by madartiste (Fairy Tail)
20. I am half-sick of shadows by notesfromtheunderworld (Fairy Tail)