Fics like Guess This Makes Me the Godfather

After sharing dinner, Arthur invites Peter up to have a drink with him and John. But as it turns out, it's that time when John's new body has a hard time being human, and it's not whiskey he's thirsty for.

You may also like

1. Discordant by Croik (Malevolent (Podcast))
2. We Make an Exception for Entities by Croik (Malevolent (Podcast), Kane and Feels (Podcast))
3. perhaps you would fear me, perhaps adore me by deadpooled (Malevolent (Podcast))
4. Out From Underneath Who You Were by thatoneweirdone (Malevolent (Podcast))
5. Miles to go Before we Sleep by Llwyden%20ferch%20Gyfrinach (The Magnus Archives (Podcast), Malevolent (Podcast))
6. Tuck Me In by Croik (Malevolent (Podcast))
7. The Main Course by Croik (Malevolent (Podcast))
8. In a Yellow Wood by oprime (Malevolent (Podcast))
9. Death of the Arthur, or, An Impasse Over Innsmouth by Stringgoblin (Malevolent (Podcast), Cthulhu Mythos - H. P. Lovecraft)
10. it's strange, but it's such a delight (to hear your voice again) by handsofink (Malevolent (Podcast))
11. How The Mighty Fall In Love by APossumWrites (Malevolent (Podcast))
12. That one time Arthur got possessed on stream and got into a top ten compilation by ListerineBubbleTea (Malevolent (Podcast))
13. Kiss Me Better by SeerOfTime (Malevolent (Podcast))
14. The Churning of Milk by zuzeca (Malevolent (Podcast), Cthulhu Mythos - H. P. Lovecraft, more)
15. For You to be a Part of Me (Again) by A_Mossy_Amethyst (Malevolent (Podcast))
16. the blind leading by ftmsteverogers (Malevolent (Podcast))
17. SCP 43023 - In the Eyes of Madness by CreaturePeaches (Malevolent (Podcast), SCP Foundation)
18. I Will Not Burn by Croik (Malevolent (Podcast), Cthulhu Mythos - H. P. Lovecraft, more)
19. All that is mine to me, all that is yours to you by Stringgoblin (Malevolent (Podcast))
20. Phagia by PrettyArbitrary (Malevolent (Podcast))