Fics like baby, it's halloween (there’s a first time for everything)

He’s not sure why, exactly, Lucy has decided she needs to spend Halloween with him. She’d mentioned something about how she’d really like to pass out candy this year, and Tim said she was more than welcome to come take over his front door, but he didn’t think she’d actually take him up on it. Now, she’s been mentioning it at least once a day for the last several days, and he’s starting to think she’s serious. Tim and Lucy spend Halloween (not) giving out candy in costume and (definitely not) skirting around their feelings for each other. It goes about exactly how you'd expect it to.

You may also like

It Takes a Village (or a division) by firstdegreefangirl (The Rookie (TV 2018))
I never knew I had a dream until that dream was you by crose84 (The Rookie (TV 2018))
One Good Time At A Time by firstdegreefangirl (The Rookie (TV 2018))
we could leave the christmas lights up 'til january by Bugsquads (The Rookie (TV 2018))
something new to fall into by fromiftowhen (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Give & Take by doomedship (The Rookie (TV 2018))
La non-demande en mariage by romantashas (The Rookie (TV 2018))
birds singing in the sycamore tree by Bugsquads (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Thinking & Knowing by crose84 (The Rookie (TV 2018))
give a little light (to get a little love back) by fromiftowhen (The Rookie (TV 2018))
blue skies and sunshine guaranteed by fromiftowhen (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Sick Days and Storytimes by firstdegreefangirl (The Rookie (TV 2018))
i met you in the dark (you lit me up) by fromiftowhen (The Rookie (TV 2018))
The First Sign by BimadaBomilyBr (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Made You Wait by poppypickle (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Something In These Walls by doomedship (The Rookie (TV 2018))
you are my craving by skittlebox (The Rookie (TV 2018))
Cards on the table, we’re both showing hearts by amaradangeli (The Rookie (TV 2018))
In The Blink of an Eye by CSM (The Rookie (TV 2018))
What's Mine Isn't Yours by Kayla1 (The Rookie (TV 2018))