Fics like Gone With the Wendigo

Sam and Dean go into the New Hampshire wilderness to investigate a new case: whole groups of hikers are getting trapped in freak blizzards and then encased in solid ice. When a blizzard hits them on the trail, they take shelter in a nearby cave for the night, only to awake to find themselves transformed into brightly colored ponies and trapped in a whole new world where zebras speak in rhyme, ponies run apple orchards, good times and positive thinking are encouraged, and friendship? Friendship is magic.

You may also like

1. Twist and Shout by gabriel, standbyme (Supernatural)
2. Eat it Twilight by liliaeth (Supernatural, Criminal Minds)
3. Forgotten by NorthernSparrow (Supernatural)
4. Defect by kikkimax (Supernatural, Criminal Minds (US TV))
5. Country of the Heart by ratherastory (Supernatural)
6. The Road So Far (This Time Around) by 8_Years_of_Silence (Supernatural)
7. Defect (multi chapter version) by kikkimax (Supernatural, Criminal Minds (US TV))
8. Past Tense by Try2CatchMe (Supernatural, Doctor Who)
9. Reality Results by Practicalsome (Criminal Minds (US TV), Supernatural)
10. Witch Doctor by Practicalsome (Supernatural, Criminal Minds (US TV))
11. Comes Knocking by Pearsforgranite (Supernatural, Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)
12. Ad Astra - latin ; "to the stars" by nhixxie (Supernatural)
13. I CARRY YOUR HEART (I CARRY IT IN MY HEART) by unicornpoe (Supernatural)
14. something suddenly everywhere by noviembre (Supernatural)
15. Any Witch Way by merle_p (Supernatural)
16. Gray by LitGal (Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Supernatural)
17. Lollies and Loki by cheshire_carroll (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural)
18. heard from your mother (she don't recognize you) by rupertgayes (Supernatural)
19. Shelter by aeli_kindara (Supernatural)
20. Drowned by eden22 (Supernatural, Criminal Minds (US TV))