Fics like Like a Fish Out of Water

AU after Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie. During the final battle with the Leviathans, God finally makes an appearance and deigns to intervene. After granting Sam and Dean a few final requests, he 'packs his bags' and takes everything supernatural in existence with him. Left with nothing to hunt, Sam talks a reluctant Dean into settling down in a small town outside of Sioux Falls. Sam seems to want them live a normal kind of life, but between the ridiculous estate sale Sam bought to furnish the house, the arrival of a very human Castiel who's overwhelmed by human emotions, and their quirky, invasive neighbors, it's anything but. Dean's having a difficult time adjusting, convinced everything couldn't be more abnormal until Sam reveals exactly what kind of life he wants to have with Dean. Dean can't deny the part of him that wants it--but can he accept it?

You may also like

  1. Bring It On Home by thecouchcarrot (Supernatural)
  2. Unfamiliar by riseofthefallenone (Supernatural)
  3. The Request by cloudyjenn (Supernatural)
  4. psalm 40:2 by unicornpoe (Supernatural)
  5. One Going On Eternity And Counting by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
  6. things happen (they do, they do, and they do) by sobsicles (Supernatural)
  7. Leader of the Pack by astolat (Supernatural)
  8. Save a Horse, Ride a Cowboy by palominopup (Supernatural)
  9. Fumbling in the Dark: Love Advice For the Romantically Impaired by leonidaslion (Supernatural)
  10. a turn of the earth by microcomets (Supernatural)
  11. I CARRY YOUR HEART (I CARRY IT IN MY HEART) by unicornpoe (Supernatural)
  12. Crazy Diamonds by pantheon_of_discord (Supernatural)
  13. Not Quite The Devil You Know by Taranea (Supernatural, Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett)
  14. omni gladio ancipiti by lifevolutionary (Supernatural)
  15. How (thanks to Gabriel) Dean and Castiel (accidentally) raised each other (and Sam). by Vee (Supernatural)
  16. Cuckoo And Nest by komodobits (Supernatural)
  17. Try-Something Tuesday by almaasi (Supernatural)
  18. Little Green Uniform by CeeLaw (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Supernatural)
  19. Forget-Me-Not Blues by noangelsinthegarrison (Supernatural)
  20. Assimilation by komodobits (Supernatural)