Fics like Gathered Safely In

Abbie Mills is a virgin. She's done a lot of things but she hasn't done that. Until now? This was brought about by an anon question to nerdygrlwonder on Tumblr about how it wasn't outside the realm of possibility that Abbie could be a virgin. Yes, not at all likely but not impossible? I took that idea and ran with it.

You may also like

1. The Extraordinary Presidents by RandolphChurchill (The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Hamilton - Miranda, more)
2. She and He by CreepingMuse (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
3. Can't Pin You Down by iamtheenemy (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
4. Darcy Lewis vs. the Multi-Verse by aForgottenWeasley (The Avengers (Marvel Movies), Thor (Movies), more)
5. Mutual Constraints by Majestrix (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
6. a more perfect Union by scifisis (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
7. we the penitent (with humble heart) by Jedi%20Buttercup (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
8. Steep by likebunnies (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
9. Chasing the North by likebunnies (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
10. In Orbit by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
11. Five Times Abbie Introduced Ichabod To Fast Food (and one time he didn't complain) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
12. Let Me Be Your Remedy by CallMeElle (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
13. [vid] Stand By You by thingswithwings (Alphas (TV), Brooklyn Nine-Nine (TV), more)
14. Blue Jeans and Thai Food by ladygray99 (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
15. Trust and Love by CastleriggCircle (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
16. Five Times Abbie Explained That Ichabod Is Married (and one time she reminded herself) by audreyii_fic (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
17. You Always Want What You're Running From by fairytalesandfolklore (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
18. Is There a Law? (The Demon Machine remix) by blathering_kat, fiarra (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
19. The Five Stages of Grief by hollowlife (Sleepy Hollow (TV))
20. The Last Rose by sneetchstar (Sleepy Hollow (TV))