Fics like It was Consensual!

Cal decides to allow her girlfriend to feed from her after starving for two weeks but is not prepared for Apollo's reaction when he walks in on them

You may also like

1. the fault, darling, is not in our stars by orphan_account (First Kill (TV 2022))
2. I Hear It's Quieter Here On the Dark Side by AeschylusRex (First Kill (TV 2022))
3. Sprung from my only hate by Witchgirl1234 (First Kill (TV 2022))
4. every unworthy thing by didacticinstruction (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
5. Laced Feed by Witchgirl1234 (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
6. It's Dangerous to be a Woman in Love by walkthatlonesomevalley (First Kill (TV 2022))
7. First kill - jealousy reversed by Roi123 (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
8. [vid] Cockroach Motherfuckers by eruthros, thingswithwings (multifandom, Arrow (TV 2012), more)
9. bloodstream by that_one_urchin (First Kill (TV 2022))
10. The Warning by TheLuxBox (First Kill (TV 2022))
11. Monster or not, you are my daughter by Qwalexa (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
12. You are Forever in My Mind by CorvusCorvidae (First Kill (TV 2022))
13. Premeditated Hunger by princess_positron (First Kill (TV 2022))
14. 5 Times Cal Simped for Juliette by Witchgirl1234 (First Kill (TV 2022))
15. Taken by Roi123 (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
16. The Purr-fect night by SqueakyDuckWriter (First Kill (TV 2022))
17. Under Love's Heavy Burden by Witchgirl1234 (First Kill (TV 2022), First Kill - V. E. Schwab (Short Story))
18. never kill a girl on the first date by overnights (First Kill (TV 2022))
19. make up your mind (let me live or let me love you) by TheGoatWithAPen (First Kill (TV 2022))
20. Love's not time's fool by Bruna_G, Melime (First Kill (TV 2022))