Fics like Buttercup

This was my submission for boxofbonesfic's Monkey Paw challenge on Tumblr. Prompt: You go to church with the Sheriff, he's there every Sunday, hearing the word, same as you. Your Mama says it's not proper, for your face to heat up and your belly to tingle every time he tips his hat in your direction asking in that low drawl if there's anything he can do for you. You know she wouldn't approve of you and him at the drive-in with no chaperone--but he's the Sheriff for goodness sake! And if you're not safe with the Sheriff, then who are you safe with?

You may also like

  1. Kinktober 2023 by myfictionaldreams (Marvel Cinematic Universe, The Avengers (Marvel Movies), more)
  2. Laisse tomber les filles by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  3. trucker friends by witch_of_the_sea (The Red Sea Diving Resort (2019), Defending Jacob (TV 2020), more)
  4. Under Watchful Eyes by snwfairy (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  5. Laestrygonia by billytea (Fresh (2022), The Devil All the Time (2020))
  6. get away with anything (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  7. Pretty Petals by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (Marvel Cinematic Universe, Captain America (Movies), more)
  8. One-offs by punyparker (Spider-Man - All Media Types, Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies), more)
  9. Give In by overrwritten (Lee Bodecker - Fandom, The Devil All the Time (2020), more)
  10. Got Any Candy by qyllenhaal (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  11. The Sweet Bye and Bye by wilhelmina_murray (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  12. Of something beautiful but annihilating by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  13. Lee Bodecker Oneshots by sebastiansluts (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  14. Desperate Affairs by georgiapeach30513 (Defending Jacob (TV 2020), Knives Out (2019), more)
  15. His Perfect Housewife by BubbleGumStan (The Devil All the Time (2020), The Devil All the Time - Donald Ray Pollock)
  16. Sweater Weather by sableseb (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  17. Suga' Bear by SlothSpaghetti (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  18. Sloth's Monstrous Kinktober 2021 by SlothSpaghetti (Marvel, MCU, more)
  19. Lonely Housewife by lostcontactwithreality28 (The Devil All the Time (2020))
  20. Dark Drabble Request 2021 by theimaginesyouneveraskedfor (The Devil All the Time (2020), Marvel Cinematic Universe, more)