Fics like Sour Cherry Pie Life

Dean has retired to the civilian life. Too bad no one told the serial killer currently stalking teenagers in Indiana.

You may also like

1. Single Malt, Double Life by mind_of_emmette (NCIS (TV 2003), Criminal Minds (US TV))
2. Not your typical damsel in distress by PepperonyOwl (Criminal Minds (US TV), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
3. How To Annoy an FBI Unit by Pipi10 (Supernatural (TV 2005), Criminal Minds (US TV))
4. Guiding Light in the Darkness Teen Wolf/ Criminal Minds. Derek Morgan by Fantastic_writer06 (Teen Wolf (TV), Criminal Minds (US TV))
5. The Fourth Horseman by NinjaPandaScholar (Supernatural (TV 2005), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
6. Shadows And Light by The_Grey_Lady_Weeps (Criminal Minds (US TV))
7. Serendipitous Meetings by sarhea (Criminal Minds (US TV), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
8. A Hard Day's Night by LadyLibby (Criminal Minds (US TV))
9. All My Exes Are Wanted in the State of Texas by MaximumDragonEnergy (Criminal Minds (US TV), White Collar (TV 2009), more)
10. Malignant by forgetmesunflower (Criminal Minds (US TV), Nightwing (Comics), more)
11. Lost Hood by Dark_Nymphs_translates (Criminal Minds (US TV), Batman - All Media Types, more)
12. Cutting the Fibrin Netting by SwampSpirit (Batman - All Media Types, Criminal Minds (US TV))
13. Why it is a bad idea to capture Bats by CyborgV2 (Batman - All Media Types, Justice League - All Media Types, more)
14. Dick Grayson: A Case Study by writersagainstwritersblock (Criminal Minds (US TV), Batman - All Media Types, more)
15. Looking Through Windows by FaithDaria (Supernatural (TV 2005))
16. Strength in numbers by radiboyn (Criminal Minds (US TV))
17. The Greatest Cake by MaximumDragonEnergy (White Collar (TV 2009), Criminal Minds (US TV))
18. gold rush by blueberryfortunes (Criminal Minds (US TV), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling)
19. Until Someone Lives in Them by lovecommahannah (Criminal Minds (US TV))
20. Criminal Magic by beeknees (Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Criminal Minds (US TV))