Fics like Backseat Serenade

Klitz and Eli nearly get their asses beat and then they make out and jizz in Klitz' car

You may also like

1. The Closet Has a Sliding Glass Door by Milk_and_Egg (The Girl Next Door (2004))
2. This Not Thing Thing by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
3. Shut Up by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
4. Paul Dano Cinematic Universe One-shots by starlight_searches (The Batman (Movie 2022), The Girl Next Door (2004), more)
5. rip bozo by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
6. The Perfect Disaster of a First Date by Milk_and_Egg (The Girl Next Door (2004))
7. There’s nothing gay about helping your friend out by cannabissalad (The Girl Next Door (2004))
8. Camboy pt. 2 by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
9. boys on film by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
10. Switch by urlkelley (The Girl Next Door (2004))
11. He's got love to give by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004), danonation - Fandom)
12. Klitz Needs To Have Some Fun by Killonic (The Girl Next Door (2004))
13. yes homo by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))
14. Paul Dano oneshots by Grossly_drawn_girl (The Batman (Movie 2022), Little Miss Sunshine, more)
15. Riddler: Into The Dano-Verse (The Batman (Movie 2022), Little Miss Sunshine (2006), more)
16. blue monday by doderickrules (The Girl Next Door (2004))
17. Klitz With A K by call_m3_angel (The Girl Next Door (2004))
18. Valentine Chocolate Box Collection by always_andromeda (For Ellen (2012), War and Peace (TV 2016), more)
19. Prom Night by neilpissyrega (The Girl Next Door (2004))
20. Shits & Giggles by orphan_account (The Girl Next Door (2004))