Fics like The Prettiest Star

Sam tries to bring back a fallen star to prove his affection to the most sought after girl in town. Thing is, it's not like he'd expect said star to be so, well, talkative.

You may also like

1. Heaven & Hell Escort Service by thejigsawtimess (Supernatural)
2. When the World Screams by K_K_TiBal (Supernatural)
3. Tempest of Oblivion by thepinupchemist (Supernatural)
4. It's a Small World (aka the Worst Ride at Disneyland) by ireadhpinenochian (Supernatural)
5. Bicker by followyourenergy (Supernatural)
6. alone together by dothraki_shieldmaiden (Supernatural)
7. Feast of the Assumptions by Amazonia_8 (Supernatural)
8. so let it out and let it in by nowhere_blake (Supernatural)
9. Meet Cute by GatesKeeper (Supernatural)
10. Once Upon A Time in a Disney Store by noxsoulmate (Supernatural)
11. On Your Guard by theproblematique (Supernatural)
12. Our Small World by needsmoreyellow (Supernatural)
13. Blackbird Fly by artsyunderstudy (Supernatural)
14. There's Only One Sure Thing That I Know by blinkiesays (Supernatural)
15. The Life After the Morning After by saltyfeathers (Supernatural)
16. Plain and Tall by destielpasta, mtothedestiel (Supernatural)
17. Knight Takes King by darkforetold (Supernatural)
18. The Breath Of All Things by KismetJeska (Supernatural)
19. Someone I Forgot to Be by MatildaMavis (Supernatural)
20. Out of the Deep by riseofthefallenone (Supernatural)