Fics like heart to heart

His eyebrows shot up. “I thought for sure you would have sworn off any chance of being near me.” “Well it was what almost made me choose the other choice, but I figured since I’m stuck with you as a mate either way, why not make the most of it.” “You don’t sound so enthusiastic,” he commented dryly. Or the one where Caroline finds her soulmate but it's the last person she expected and she has to deal with it.

You may also like

  1. i don't have a choice (but i'd still choose you) by generousheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  2. The Queen and the Wolf by supernutellastuff (The Vampire Diaries (TV), The Originals (TV))
  3. You Went Under My Skin, And Didn't Want To Get Out by eternal_optimist (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  4. I will be inevitable by LynyrdLionheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  5. Sweet As by LaLainaJ (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  6. What is Happening? by Sabineholterman (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  7. I believe in yesterday by Rivercedar (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  8. Reasons Klaus Sucks by chelz95 (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  9. Everywhere With You by LaLainaJ (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  10. Dual Nature by LynyrdLionheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  11. Worth It by mon-amour-eternel (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  12. Texting by venomandchampagne (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  13. Matchmaker by emeraldvixen (The Vampire Diaries (TV), The Vampire Diaries & Related Fandoms, more)
  14. Bound Together by soapmaniac22 (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  15. where it began: by endoftheline7 (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  16. Blood In Our Throat by LynyrdLionheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  17. such an imprint on your heart by generousheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV))
  18. The Champion and the Dragon Master by LynyrdLionheart (The Vampire Diaries (TV), Pocket Monsters | Pokemon - All Media Types)
  19. all you need to grow inside my spine by but_seriously (The Vampire Diaries (TV), The Originals (TV))
  20. There’s a devil on my shoulder where the angels used to be (and he’s calling me the Queen) by meet_the_girl_who_can (The Vampire Diaries (TV))