Fics like Pumpkin Apple Pie

He should’ve left when he had the chance.

You may also like

1. slice of life by dreamyskyyy (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
2. Official Meeting by Nightgirl08 (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
3. You Deserve It by Sir_Subpar (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
4. Shell of a Friend (or: How One Unseen Force Ruined My Entire Day) by bonnielunkas (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
5. sweetly by loveing_you_isharsh (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
6. The Forbidden Fruit by moondancer150 (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
7. We've Been Talking To A Rotten Apple by h_url (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game), We've Been Talking To A Rotten Apple (Andy's Apple Farm AU))
8. Eyes in the Background (AAF and welcome home crossover) by OkaIsntOkay (Welcome Home - Clown Illustration, Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
9. Unbreakable Heart (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
10. A Crossover of Vengeance by RoseJigglypuff76, orphan_account (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
11. Waterlogged by ThisProfileIsBlank (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
12. Get Out of My Swamp!!! (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
13. Camp Eastwood! ~ An Andy's Apple Farm Swap AU by milkyway_wishes_sys (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
14. A(ze's) Cool Character Elimination Show Again! (ACCESA) by TheFunnyMan2763 (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game), Gravity Falls, more)
15. I spy by foxylover123 (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
16. A Man-Made Hell by TransgenderGamblingNetwork_system (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
17. CrossRonpa: FATE'S GAMBLE — A Fandom Crossover Work by BelldoesStuff (Date Everything! (Sassy Chap Games Video Game), プロジェクトセカイ カラフルステージ！| Project SEKAI COLORFUL STAGE! (Video Game), more)
18. To Forget by orphan_account (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
19. You’re not what you seem by moondancer150 (Andy's Apple Farm (Video Game))
20. HELP ME DELIVER A PIZZA! by Chemical_Handbag, skullotonin (Homestuck, South Park, more)