Fics like Something No One Expected

It starts when Jeremy overhears something he wasn't meant to. Something to do with Everett's past (or not-so-past) feelings for Jeremy's boyfriend.

You may also like

1. The games we play (The lies we live) by otomes_and_tears (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
2. A mean boy I meet at the beach by TheUnicornPrincess (Our Life: Beginnings & Always (Visual Novel), XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
3. Forbidden Things Have A Secret Charm by OsiriaRose33, Osiria_Rose89 (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
4. Love's Gonna Get You Down (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
5. A Worthless, Terrible Love Story by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
6. Peach Blossoms by otomes_and_tears (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
7. Sine Qua Non by YontifexMaximus (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
8. xoxo blood droplets x reader! by orphan_account (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
9. Stop I'm Trying To Work... by RemyBee (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
10. Frozen Food, Hot Coffee, and Relationship Updates by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
11. What is the Exercise Equivalent of Carrying Around an Everett Gray? by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
12. Confession Time by WynterWonderland (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
13. A Twisted Sense of Love [Submission of gb-patch fanfiction contest!] by UsagiChanP2 (XOXO Droplets (Video Game), XOXO Blood Droplets, more)
14. Someone Right Under Your Nose by Overlord_of_Pairings (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
15. Please Excuse My Dumb Ass Boyfriends by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
16. The Haze of a Dream by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
17. Not a Christmas Meeting! by shishizuzu (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
18. I could tolerate being together forever by Saki_PIKO (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
19. Triangles by Crazy_Pairing_Person (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))
20. these hands not fit for holding (XOXO Droplets (Video Game))