Fics like masquerading

Your boyfriend surprises you in the bedroom, wearing a strange mask and unfamiliar clothing. You have no reason to suspect he isn't who he appears to be - right? Or; you mistake Michael for your boyfriend, whoops.

You may also like

  1. Virginal by skeleton_detective (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  2. Lighter Fluid by slasher_abyss (Halloween Movies - All Media Types, Halloween (2018))
  3. Potent by skeleton_detective (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  4. Michael's early Treat by ab824020 (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  5. The Devil's Swan by WriterDMathis (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), Halloween (Movies - Zombie))
  6. always forever by rottenstrawberrymilk (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
  7. Courted by Death by WickedVices (Hannibal (TV), Hannibal Lecter Series - All Media Types, more)
  8. Welcome home Michael by Gogotti (Halloween (Movies - Zombie), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  9. Rest for the Wicked by Korpuskat (Halloween (2018), Halloween (Movies - Green))
  10. Twisted Love by Fallinglikestars21 (Scream (Movies), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), more)
  11. Everyone Run! by Lemoon_green (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Movies), more)
  12. Horror Villains x Reader Smut Compilation by PastelPukePink (A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010), A Nightmare on Elm Street (Movies 1984-1994), more)
  13. 'For my Michael' by Hooman4ever (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  14. Food by sinfulmarie (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  15. Leave Me Alone by Cakeawake100 (Scream (Movies), Dead by Daylight (Video Game), more)
  16. A Buncha Hand Stuff by yourhorrormom (Star Trek, Alien Series, more)
  17. Letting off Some Steam by baphzz (Dead by Daylight (Video Game), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  18. Cadence by Korpuskat (Halloween (Movies - Green), Halloween (Movies 1978-2002))
  19. Starved by slothinsocks (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), Halloween (Movies - Green), more)
  20. Dancing with Death by WickedVices (Halloween (Movies 1978-2002), Halloween (Movies - Zombie), more)