Fics like If At First You Don’t Succeed

Written for the following Masquerade prompt and reworked and presented for Saturday Night Specials: They have to consummate the marriage on the first night. Would love to see some animosity, maybe some awkwardness, and it’s not immediately the greatest sex in the world. But they soldier on because it’s their duty, and maybe the next time, it’s easier. Can be a/b/o, but doesn’t have to be.

You may also like

1. I'll Give You What You Like by soulmatecest (Supernatural RPF)
2. Slick by Jay%20Tryfanstone (Supernatural RPF)
3. Project Get Jared Banged by soulmatecest (Supernatural RPF)
4. Full Service Firm by rivkat (Supernatural RPF)
5. Belly for Two Quartets by crumbler (Supernatural RPF)
6. Calls of Fate by ObsidianRomance (Supernatural RPF)
7. The Break Up by tammywrites (Supernatural RPF)
8. Black Cat Mercantile by deadlybride (Supernatural RPF)
9. Even a Man Who is Pure in Heart by bunnymaccool (Supernatural RPF)
10. Wild is the Wind by Nutkin (Supernatural RPF)
11. Light My Morning Sky with Burning Love by doilycoffin (Supernatural RPF)
12. 29 Days by ashtraythief (Supernatural RPF)
13. Garbage by compo67 (Supernatural RPF)
14. Teaching Him to Trust by morganaDW (Supernatural RPF)
15. Oh, When You Love It by soulmatecest (Supernatural RPF)
16. Underneath It All by ashtraythief (Supernatural RPF, CW Network RPF)
17. Heathens by gothpandaotaku (Supernatural RPF)
18. Sleeping With the Enemy by tammywrites (Supernatural RPF)
19. Black on Bronze by kelleigh (Supernatural RPF)
20. But Then, My Homework Was Never Quite Like This by nyxocity (Supernatural RPF)