Fics like Ever since New York

Hailey is curious to know when exactly Jay understood he wanted to spend the rest of his life with her. or — a post-proposal one shot.

You may also like

1. when I close my eyes I feel it all again by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
2. Fighting for Your Love by onecpd (Chicago PD (TV))
3. Through the late night by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
4. All My Holidays by anniesardors (Chicago PD (TV))
5. 6 PM in New York by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
6. Beautiful Stranger by sumsflowers (Chicago PD (TV))
7. 143 by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
8. Hot Cops by Lady_RhaeSnow18 (Chicago PD (TV))
9. Fireside by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
10. peace after the hurricane by andifimyours (Chicago PD (TV))
11. Ten Things by Serenfor10 (Chicago PD (TV))
12. Right Where You Left Me by chloejane1 (Chicago PD (TV))
13. This Love (left a permanent mark) by sqiridakos (Chicago PD (TV), Upstead - Fandom)
14. if you're broken I'll mend ya by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
15. Mine by Upsteadsgirl (Chicago PD (TV))
16. If I had a heart by fank0ne (Chicago PD (TV))
17. Dream of Some Epiphany by onecpd (Chicago PD (TV))
18. I watched it begin again by doingitwithabrokenheart (Chicago PD (TV))
19. For All Of It by sumsflowers (Chicago PD (TV))
20. Pieces of the Puzzle by onecpd (Chicago PD (TV))